Week 10: I, Rigoberta Menchú (Menchú)

 Hi guys! I hope you guys are all having a good start to your week so far. This week's reading felt very emotional and dealt with some serious topics that are also very relevant today in Canada. I think it is really important to recognize the struggles discussed in I, Rigoberta Menchú, as not everyone has the same or similar experiences to those of the family within the book. I think that this book put a lot of things in perspective for me and how important it is to recognize and appreciate stories of those from different cultures, history’s, backgrounds from us as it can make us more aware of societal injustices that we see in our everyday lives. Although the book deals with widely important topics about social injustice, land and people exploitation, and a clear class hierarchy, the book is written in a way that is easy to understand. I feel like most of the time with books that are so dense in themes and topics I typically have a really hard time understanding and grasping the content fully, but in I, Rigoberta Menchú’s case it was digestible and honestly made me more invested in the stories at hand. 


I think one part that stood out to me was from the chapter “Conflict with the Landowners and the Creation of the CUC”. This chapter in general was very disturbing, reading about how the families constantly had to move land and no longer had things to eat or utensils to cook with as the landowners just came in and “claimed '' that the land was never theirs in the first place. The government then goes on to claim that the land belongs to the nation, but Rigoberta says that it is almost ironic that they come at the time to claim the land after her people have put in all the labor to cultivate it. She then begins to understand that all the systems of injustices are connected, and how they didn’t realize they couldn’t trust the government until then. I think this book provides a very personal experience into the injustices that were felt to her family and her community around her, and I think that this added to the power this book had over me. 


Along with all the sadness of the injustices and displacement that happened throughout the book, Rigoberta’s family goes through very traumatic experiences, yet she still appears empowered at the end of the book. She has taken her trauma of losing her family, her brother, her land, culture, and overall oppression and has turned it around so that she can share her stories and empower others. The last chapter of the book especially highlights this, as she talks about the lucky opportunity of being able to talk about her people to others and get her story out so it can be hers again. 


My question for you guys is what do you make of the questioning of her faiths at the end of the book?


Comments

  1. Daniel OrizagaMarch 20, 2023 at 10:38 PM

    "She then begins to understand that all the systems of injustices are connected". It is true, but she has also understood how they work in each particular situation in which she has had to live, and she has developed strategies with other fighting groups to combat them. However, the end of the book already warns us of certain attitudes with which the book would be received. How do you imagine its current reception in Canada, if it was the first time it was released?

    ReplyDelete
  2. DaisyMarch 22, 2023 at 3:27 PM

    HI jordan! Thanks for your lovely post this week. I think it was very powerful to have this story be told from someone who went through such hard times and be able to share her experience afterwards. To answer your question, I think that it is common to question your relationship with your faith after really tough times, but it sounded like she was using it in a way to help her heal and find meaning.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Chanya ChawlaMarch 22, 2023 at 6:33 PM

    Hi Jordan- thank you for a well-thought and written post. I must agree with you that Menchú's writing style made this reading a lot more digestable.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 12: My Tender Matador (Lemebel)

  Hi everyone! I hope you are all having a good start to the week. We are almost done this semester, we can do it!! This week I chose to read My Tender Matador by Pedro Lemebel. Personally, although this book had an interesting story line and dealt with really important themes I found myself struggling to read it. I kept getting pulled out of the trance of the story and had to keep going back to reground myself back into the book. However, I did get some clarification and background on the political scene and attempted assassination from Jon’s lecture which helped me to understand Carlos’ character a bit better. I found his relation with Queen of the Corner to be quite toxic. He was always just using her either for her space to keep his weapons, or as a distraction from getting caught by the police checkpoint, and always just coming and going as he pleased. I think it was obvious that she was in love with him from the start yet he kept on controlling her for his own personal benefi...
Read more

Week 7: 100 Years of Solitude Part 1 (Márquez)

  Hi everyone! I hope everyone had a restful and relaxing break. I have to say I am really enjoying this book so far. When I first saw the family tree at the beginning I thought I was in for a long, hard, and confusing book (which this one was at times), but mostly I found myself being fascinated by the multitude of stories and characters in the book. From the founding of the town, the gypsy arrival, seeing ice, love triangles, incest, this book had it all. I particularly enjoyed reading about the marriages between Rebbecca and Crepsi and then Aureliano and Remedios. I loved the sibling (or adopted sibling) rivalry that grew between the adopted Rebbecca and Amaranta. The anticipation of the weddings and what was going to happen kept me hooked to the book for a bit.  Jon and his lecture were definitely correct when he said that this was a book you have to stick with more than just pick it up when you feel like reading. I get very distracted easily and have a hard time focusing,...
Read more

Week 2: “Mama Blanca’s Memoirs” (De La Parra)

  Hi everyone! I found this week's reading rather interesting as I haven’t read a lot of memoirs in the past. I am not a very fast reader so this reading took me a while and I found myself doing it in shorter blocks of time, which I wish I hadn't as I felt like every time I began again I was reading something completely different. For next week I am going to try and read the reading in longer sit down sessions so I can truly absorb the content more and not feel so out of place when I start reading it again. That being said, I did enjoy this book as I loved its attention to detail, especially when discussing the hair or the features of her other family members. I always appreciate this attention to detail, as for someone who watches a lot of film and TV (being a film major) it helps me to paint a more detailed image in my head, which overall makes the story more interesting to me. I found the part where she was discussing in intense detail about her hair and how her mother fe...
Read more